Research finds BME women more likely on zero-hours contracts

TUC and Race on the agenda (ROTA) research finds BME women more likely on zero-hours contracts


The TUC and Race on the agenda (ROTA) have warned that structural racism in the labour market is trapping Black and minority ethnic (BME) workers on low pay and in insecure work. The warning comes as the TUC and ROTA release a joint report which reveals how BME workers are hugely overrepresented among those workers on zero-hours contracts.

According to the new analysis, around one in six zero-hours contract workers are BME, even though BME workers make up just one in nine workers overall.

BME women are the most disproportionately affected group, followed by BME men. BME women are almost twice as likely to be on zero-hours contracts as white men (4.5% compared to 2.5%). And they are almost one and a half times more likely to be on zero-hours contracts compared to white women (3.2%).

One-sided flexibility

The TUC and ROTA say zero-hours contracts are “the most egregious example of one-sided flexibility at work”, handing the employer total control over their workers’ hours and earning power.

New TUC polling of working people, conducted by GQR Research, shows how BME workers are the sharp end of this one-sided arrangement:

  • Two in five (40%) BME workers on insecure contracts report that they faced the threat of losing their shifts if they turned down work, compared to a quarter (25%) of white insecure workers;
  • More than half (51%) of BME insecure workers report struggling to manage their household finances due to insufficient hours, compared to two in five (39%) white insecure workers.

The new polling also shows half of BME insecure workers (50%) have been allocated a shift at less than a day’s notice, and almost half of BME insecure workers (45%) have had shifts cancelled with less than a day to go.

This instability means workers never know how much they will earn, and their income is subject to the whims of managers. It makes it hard for workers to plan their lives, look after their children and get to medical appointments.

The new polling shows that BME insecure workers are particularly likely to want more hours and a more stable contract:

  • Three in five (60%) BME insecure workers want more hours of work compared with three in ten (30%) who do not – while less than half (49%) of white insecure workers want to work more hours;
  • More than half of BME (52%) insecure workers on a variable-hours contract would like a fixed-hours contract. Just 27% would prefer their existing arrangement.

Tackling structural racism

The TUC and ROTA say the pandemic has shone a light on the inequalities faced by BME workers and must spur government action to tackle structural racism in the labour market – which was missing from the recommendations of the recent Sewell Report.

BME workers are over-represented in insecure jobs, which have limited rights, endemic low pay and face disproportionately high Covid-19 mortality rates. Recent TUC research found workers in more insecure jobs are twice as likely to die from Covid-19 as those in less insecure occupations.
In addition, BME workers have borne the brunt of the economic downturn that has accompanied the pandemic. Recent TUC analysis found the BME unemployment rate was rising three times as fast as the white unemployment rate.

Moving forward

To help tackle structural racism and inequalities in the labour market, the TUC and ROTA are calling for:

  • A ban on zero-hours contracts.
  • For all workers to have a right to a contract which reflects their normal hours of work.
  • New corporate reporting obligations to force bad employers to detail or justify the extent of the use of exploitative work practices like zero-hours contracts.
  • The introduction of ethnic minority pay gap reporting.

TUC General Secretary Frances O’Grady said, “No matter your race or background, everyone deserves to be treated fairly at work. “But the pandemic has exposed beyond any doubt the huge inequalities BME people face at work.

“Too many BME workers are stuck on zero-hours contracts, and face a triple whammy of low pay, limited rights, and an increased risk of dying from the virus.

“This is what structural racism at work looks like – BME workers getting trapped in jobs with the worst pay and the worst conditions, struggling to pay the bills and feed their families."

ROTA CEO, Maurice Mcleod, suggested, “As our economy recovers from the pandemic and the impact of Brexit, we are likely to see an increase in precarious contracts and pressure on workers’ conditions and pay as employers try to navigate the new environment.

This recovery and reorganisation of our economy should not be carried out on the backs of black and brown workers though. People from marginalised communities are already most likely to find themselves on these types of contracts and this is further embedding inequality into our society.

“Ignoring the impact of structural workplace racism on our society will see inequality grow and moves us even further away from the equal, thriving society we all want to live in.

“If we want an economy that everyone can engage in, we need to enshrine workers’ rights in our legislation and protect workers from precarious, one-sided working arrangements.”

Click here to access the TUC and ROTA report.

Posted: June 28, 2021